Sea Pony

Like Luschen, I swam into the cave under the ship and got it on my 4th cast. We either found the best spot or had amazing luck.

it takes about 30 minute. maybe 40.

Got him in only 50 casts in 15 minutes. :) Thought it would take longer after hearing that it took other people over 200 casts.

After 66 casts (43 Raw Rainbow Fin Albacores, 18 Oily Blackmouths, 4 Firefin Snappers and one crate with Coarse Blasting Powlder) I finally got it. It wasn't as bad as I thought.

Yay! I finally got my Sea Pony!! =) After about 250 casts this little one popped up. I'm so excited!!

Hurray! I sat down to catch this today and after maybe twenty minutes of fishing it came up! I didn't count how many casts, but I do have about a stack of Rainbow Fin Albacore xD

Noliena // Moon Guard

ive done over 600 casts now an still no seapony :( i swear i have the worst luck in the world (of warcraft)
-acouple hrs later- 950 casts an it dropped bout f*****g time i say

Got this just last night. Took about 20 casts off the dock. Awesome!

Got this little cutie on my 5th cast which was a nice change since i been grinding the sea turtle mount to no avail.
will the pet become boe at some point? would love to fish up more for my alts if so.

Didn't know this little cuttie existed casted my first line and there it was eeep

Takes lots of Patience for this Cutie! I believe 1 in 250 casts in about correct. Took me about three hours for this and about 300 Casts. There was about 10 other people farming for it near me, and I was the last one there. I was determined to get this Little Pony, and it's now my favorite Vanity Pet out there! Good Luck to everyone still farming! :)

First day I lvl'd my fishing from 250 all the way to 300 without picking up the pet. Following day I logged ran to the waters edge cast and to my surprise there it was on the first cast. Talk about happy :P

Really weird drop rate, gotten it on every character EXCEPT my main lol :D Really cool pet though and worth the farming.

Got it on my 396th cast. Only did about 100 a day. Glad to add this to my collection.

johnny boy, i dont think so.
just time, but its pretty cute and it didnt take me too long to get him, i got him right of the docks

Workin on gettin this guy and wonderin, does it help to use any kind of fishing skill increase (like the aquadynamic fish attractor)? plz send me a message if u know the answer

I was fishing Shipwreck Debris on a daily basis but only getting Sealed Crates. Today I decided to have a crack at open water fishing and got it on my 28th cast!

Just got this cute little guy! SO excited, I never get the rare drops. I was at around 50 fishing skill when starting to farm, in less than an hour I hit 158 and there he was. I was fortunate enough to get a few sealed crates and received some nice loot as well. There is a spawn point for the crates at the end of the dock directly to the left of the alliance portal.

Ran to the east side of the island, swam down into the cave under the wrecked ship. 3 casts on one toon, seven on the other :D
3 cast toon was 565 fishing and the 7 cast toon was 265 fishing. Gooc Luck!

It took me two days and 500+ casts.....I love my new Sea Pony. I fished all around the island and finally got her in the underground cave.