Sea Pony
Binds when picked up
Use: Teaches you how to summon this companion.
Idles about.
Splashing (on summon); bubbling (constant); vocalizations (on-click)
This pet is obtained via open-water coastal fishing on the Darkmoon Island. See El's Extreme Anglin's guide: Catching Sea Pony for more information.
Players may only farm for this pet one week per month due to the Darkmoon Island only being accessible the first week out of every month.
The Sea Pony has a unique summoning animation in which the player's hands are enveloped with globes of water, and a splashing animation and noise is made upon the pet's spawning.

I always wanted a pony when I was a small gnome, but I never imagined I'd find one living in a bubble! No... it's not quite the pony I dreamed of as a child, but it does provide a percolating playmate for my water elemental.






Loading...
Vs.
Elemental
Vs.
Magic
I just got my little guy in about 20 casts, I took a SS of me and my new pony and my abyssal seahorse , and submitted to wowhead, cant wait to see it up ><
Of course as soon as I posted this I got it. 311 casts.
I got this on my 14th cast just 40 ft to the left of the docks. Not sure it's worth the effort to try and find some special fishing location.
Just had to post cuse a friend told me to fish in front of the DMRabbit cave to have better luck catching this guy (between 10-100 casts) but after more then 100 casts there was nothing. So I checked wowhead and the cords were way off. Its actually an underwater cave about halfway up the east side of the island and out to the edge of the water shelf (when you see the fatige bar your out far enough). You'll see a large sunken ship. Its just below the ship.
Second cast. Much better rate.
I got mine in between 30-50 casts.
Fellow guildies also had varying catch totals between 50-200.
So I'd say it might even be a 1 in 300 chance.
Edit: Husband got it after 939 casts.
3 casts. Pony wat?!?!
I almost pooped myself.
UPDATE: Logged at Midnight as soon as the patch came out & did all the Darkmoon Faire quests. 6 hours in, I did the Deathmatch with some friends (as a joke) and ended up winning and getting the achievement.
Went to work on this and 17 casts in, I caught it. This is after I got the Sewer Rat & Oozling drops quickly yesterday.
I'm having a good week. :) Thank you WowGods!
Fished for 150+ casts in various spots on the island, and while I didn't get the Sea Pony, I did get the funny hat that makes a debris pool. So I put that on and went to the cave. Fished for a bit more, not too sure as it was really late, but nothing came up. Logged off still in the cave and the next day, fished for about 20 minutes when I caught my precious Sea Pony! I'd say fish the cave, seems to work for lots of folks. Happy hunting!
Based on the 3 times I've caught one, the rate is closer to 1 in 400 casts. But I have to admit it's worth it. This guy is cute as all get out!