Toothy

WOOT! Just got Toothy! Now for the other 3...

Gone 5 years now, no signs of Toothy.... running low on water, will prolly run out of food in a couple weeks..

alex...out...

I heard about him from a friend i got the quest and within 20 mintues i had toothy on my first try! I havent been as successful on getting the other 3 :/

me and my bro went throught alot of research for this guy now im freakin sad cuz i didnt get him in the bag of fishing treasures he was my favorite pet if it dosent work with the other character than i will stop my companion pet hunts

fished this croc out of my daily bag today... then my sister got the same pet; we're both collectors, and this made us very happy. as far as crocs go, hes a real cutie pie i will definently be keeping an eye on the shattrath fishing dailies for crocolisks in the city

It was a great idea to combine fishing and minipets :) I like both.I have been so unlucky with these crocs...On my old priest,I had like 3 or all 4 of them (when the drop rate was lower),but now I find it really hard to obtain them.The only one Ive gotten so far is Toothy,not that I aint happy about getting him...just means more daily´s for me :) I´ll get there.Happy hunting,everyone! <3 :}

Not sure if its just my luck but I got this cutie and Chuck on the first try for each. Good luck to you all!!!

Haven't played in almost a year. Just dusted off my account, and got Toothy on my first daily since getting back on. Great re-start to a fishing career!

alright i've been doing these quests for atleast 6 months and havnt gotten a single pet yet, I do the quests almost every day and nothing. do the crocs only drop if you do the croc in the city quest? or do they come from all quest reward bags?

I've recently been trying to get Toothy on an alt.

I got the first three: Chuck, Muckbreath and Snarly in successive treasure bags. However, after ten more treasure bags not only do I not have Toothy I haven't received any of the other pets either. That's no pet in 10 treasure bags !!

It's now 12 treasure bags and no pet, petitioned a GM and got a response that there was no known issue but they would investigate further ......

Finally got this last croc pet for my alt, in the 32nd croc bag

I got this little guy to drop on the first time I completed this quest! Super happy! Now on to the next one!

Today was the day at last. After waiting for what seemed like forever to get crocolisk #3, corcolisk #4 which was Toothy dropped. The quest to get all 4 is now finished and I couldn't be happier. As for the 60% drop rate, that cannot be right. Anyone who are trying to get these, just keep at it. Eventually, you'll get them all.

At least for me the 60% drop rate seems not to be true. I haven't got a single bucket in a looooooong time. And even before that the bucket drop rate was way lower than 60% for me... and only Muckbreath and Chuck, no Toothy. :(

Edit: Well... I threw away the buckets that I had been carrying (to remind Old Man Barlow which ones I don't need), and the very next time I did the fishing in Stormwind daily Toothy dropped. It might have been just RNG having a laugh at me, though.

I have been trying to get my last little croc for quite some time. I am not sure if anybody else is experiencing the same problem but it seems ever since the last big patch came out, every time I do the "crocolisks in the city" quest I no longer get a pet to drop. Prior to the patch I ALWAYS got one, just not the last one I need :( - Can anybody confirm this? Happy Hunting.....eerrrrr fishing.

I Just got him on my first try. I think it should be venderable at least even tho it's never a lot of money at least you get something out of all that work.

I got this little guy the second time I've done any outland fishing dailies.

i think selling them would make them less special, plus it makes getting all four that much sweeter!