This isn't a bug, but a question. It's also very petty, and I freely admit it. But I'm curious.
After some dedicated effort on my part this past month, I've climbed my way to #4 on my realm for total pets collected. The top spot is within reach, and I have a plan to achieve it. Once you move to PetScore, I'm sure I'll drop a bit, but for now I'm enjoying it.
I've been comparing my collection against a guildie, Maizing, as I rose through the ranks. When I look at her collection, it says "486 of 509 unique pets — A PHENOMENAL collection!" Yet when I go to my own collection, I get "495 of 523 unique pets — An AMAZING collection!"
I have more than her. Why is my collection only amazing and not phenomenal?