Thanks for your suggestions! Our party went off without a hitch.
I think we had the most fun with Pin the tail on the Sewer Rat.
I ended up creating fictional faction called Goldshire Goodies
(My guild name on Llane). I had party attendees (3 of us) complete pet collecting quests to up their reputation. To make tracking easier, I created a website through google (free). I can't post a full on link to site because I haven't posted to the WarcraftPets forum enough. You might be able to find it by going to google. com/sites/Vermonterlevel1.
I'm not a web designer and the site is very simple - so be gentle pretty please.
Thanks again for taking the time to make suggestions. Feel free to use any of these ideas to host your own in-game/out-of-game party.Vermonter