So long story short got all the pets for raiding with leashes, then loaned my pets out to a couple of close friends to get them theirs, looked in my pet journal and I have 3 bigglesworths listed now. The first extra showed up after the first time I loaned the pets out, the second extra after the next friend. Its not a ui glitch because to test it I leveled the original pet then went and leveled the first extra I got to level 2 just to be sure. Has anyone else ran into this glitch yet?
There might a bug where if you complete the achievement, cage any of the pets, then relearn them, the game thinks you've "re-earned" the achievement and gives you another Mr. Bigglesworth. It's likely to get fixed "soon" lol.
Feel free to browse through Perks N Peeves, my vanity pet collecting blog!
That's what I was thinking was happening though now I'm looking at the pets since they're not tradeable wondering "now what do I do with them." Can't trade them only thing I can do with the extras (besides leveling them for no reason) is release them which I hate doing.
Same thing happened to me and a guildmate. We temporarily traded the pets each of us was missing and got our achievement and Mr. B. A while later I noticed that I had two of them. A while after that I noticed that I had three. I checked with my guildmate and they had three as well.
I'm glad there is a limit of 3 of each pet or I am pretty sure I'd have a couple hundred Mr. Bigglesworths by now.