Dragonwizard wrote:Is it possible that you can only get him one once per toon?
I'm normally skeptical about these hidden drop modifiers, but I think you might actually be onto something here. I've had 2 or 3 over the years, and now you mention it, each of those was on a different toon, shortly after they started fishing in the area. I've since been back with my main on a few occasions, trying to farm one to sell, and have had zero luck for several hours.
Probably just as likely it's just the RNG, but it might be something to bear in mind.