Akycha wrote:I have a friend who is an alcoholic do that this last week. Fish one up while already having one. However I don't know if it was on a character she'd previously caught one on or not.

Thanks, good to know that I might get lucky with another one at some point.

So I was wondering if the Sea Pony can still drop when fishing around Darkmoon Isle for a character who hasn't caught it before, but now has access to this pet due to another character on their account learning it in the past. In other words, if you have a Sea Pony in your Pet Journal can you catch ...