Is there something that I'm missing in regards to how you guys are tracking this?

Utilizing realms outside of your standard time frame can be an excellent way to go looking for pets. If your serious about pet collecting and don't mind leveling and alt try rolling on an oceanic server(If you are not on one of course) just to get more access to ideal time period.

Using quest items is a really simple way to gain a lot of tickets with little to no effort. If you use the mod auctionator you can import the following list that I made: *** Darkmoon Faire A Treatise on Strategy Adventurer's Journal Banner of the Fallen Captured Insignia Imbued Crystal Monstrous Egg...

Wow, there are some incredibly patient people out there. I think even the longest match I have had couldn't have been more than 40 rounds.

This already exists look up Pet Battle Teams at curse.