My first pet battle in Ashenvale, I found it second to a Forest Moth, well, I had caught the Moth, and you can't catch two pets in a single battle. After about an hour searching, I found one again second to a squirrel, and accidently killed it, I could have punched myself. Finally after about another forty minutes, I found it second to a toad, and caught it that time.
514 pets
My first pet battle in Ashenvale, I found it second to a Forest Moth, well, I had caught the Moth, and you can't catch two pets in a single battle. After about an hour searching, I found one again second to a squirrel, and accidently killed it, I could have punched myself. Finally after about another forty minutes, I found it second to a toad, and caught it that time.